Love at First Slice: Must-Try Pizza Places in SLO CAL

A slice of Alaskan spirit in sunny California 

📍104 Bridge Street, Arroyo Grande, CA 93420

Starting off in Arroyo Grande, California with a laid-back pizza place called Klondike Pizza. This pizzeria has been owned and operated by a local family since 1988 and has become a SLO CAL favorite. The owners brought a piece of their Alaskan roots with them, incorporating the state’s unique flavors into their menu, most notably, their reindeer sausage, shipped straight from Alaska.   

Klondike Pizza is serving up fluffy crust pizzas that supply a satisfying cheese-pull you can only dream of. Choose from any of their loaded topping pizzas or create your own concoction! Aside from pizza, Klondike has subs, salads, burgers and delicious garlic bread!

What truly sets Klondike apart is its fun, laid-back atmosphere. Guests are served peanuts to snack on, and it is encouraged to toss the shells right on the floor, adding a playful touch to the experience. Locals have been flocking here for over 20 years, and once you visit, you will understand why. 

A newcomer to the SLO CAL pizza scene 

📍156 1/2 Ocean Front Ave, Cayucos, CA 93430

Pie in the Sky Pizza has quickly earned love in SLO CAL. Opened by two local restaurant entrepreneurs, this pizzeria is serving up delicious bites right along the shore in Cayucos. Pie in the Sky is an artisan pizza made using sourdough, naturally fermented in-house. You can opt in for pizza by the slice or a whole 16-inch pizza with options ranging from classic toppings to their rotating seasonal special.  

Do not miss their homemade ranch dressing and drizzles of hot honey, which elevate each bite to the next level. Whether you are grabbing a quick slice or indulging in a whole pizza by the shore, Pie in the Sky is a must-stop for pizza lovers exploring SLO CAL’s coastline.

The perfect post-beach bite 

📍787 Main St, Morro Bay, CA 93442

Next up on our SLO CAL pizza tour is Pizza Port! This family-owned pizza place has been serving the community for over 35 years and has been a longstanding Morro Bay favorite. Pizza Port is crafting delicious house made dough daily and choosing intricate arrays of toppings. Their menu includes a variety of specialty pizzas, calzones, breadsticks, and hot sandwiches, ensuring there is something for everyone. Pizza Port is the perfect pizza place for a slice after a long day of beach excursions in Morro Bay! 

Pizzas made at 1000-degrees Fahrenheit  

📍1145 24th St Suite D, Paso Robles, CA 93446

Craving some cheesy deliciousness after a long day of wine tasting or horseback riding? Rustic Fire Pizza in Paso Robles has you covered! Located near downtown, Rustic Fire is the go-to place for cheesy deliciousness after a day of experiencing all that Paso Robles has to offer. 

Rustic Fire specializes in brick-fired pizzas with perfectly blistered crusts and fresh, flavorful toppings. The pizza ovens are used to cook everything, from pizza crust to sandwich bread to croutons, at over 1000 degrees Fahrenheit. Their menu includes classic options like Margherita and Pepperoni, as well as unique pizza creations like Thai Chicken or Roasted Garlic Shrimp, that pair well with their locally sourced wine and craft beer.  

Aside from their pizzas, Rustic Fire offers tasty appetizers, salads, and desserts (do not skip the brookie), making it the ideal spot for a full dining experience. The inviting ambiance and commitment to quality make Rustic Fire a standout in Paso Robles’ culinary scene. 

45 years of Italian comfort food

📍1101 Price St, Pismo Beach, CA 93449

A beloved gem in Pismo Beach, Del’s Pizzeria has been serving pizza lovers since 1973. This old-school pizza place brings a nostalgic charm, complete with checkered tablecloths and a welcoming atmosphere that makes you feel right at home. Serving homemade Italian comfort food, Del’s will make you feel right at home.  

Del’s is known for its well-portioned pizza crusts, loaded with generous portions of toppings and baked to perfection. Their menu features classic combinations as well as innovative options like their “Shell Beach Road,” pepperoni, linguica, pineapple, garlic, and onion. After a day spent soaking up the sun or walking along the Pismo Beach Pier, Del’s Pizzeria is the perfect spot to refuel with a comforting slice (or five). Pair your pizza with one of their crisp salads or hearty pasta dishes for a truly satisfying meal.

Detroit-style or Neapolitan? The choice is yours! 

📍570 Higuera St #2, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401

When it comes to pizza, Bear & The Wren in San Luis Obispo sets the bar high. This trendy downtown SLO spot offers a refined dining experience, specializing in wood-fired Neapolitan and Detroit-style pizzas. The warm, rustic interior and open kitchen create an intimate atmosphere, perfect for date nights or small gatherings.   

Their Neapolitan pizzas are made with a soft, airy crust and topped with high-quality ingredients like fresh mozzarella, prosciutto and arugula. Meanwhile, the Detroit-style options feature a thick, crispy crust and bold flavors that will have you coming back for more. The famous “Bee Stang” pizza is a must-have. Bear & The Wren’s dedication to locally sourced ingredients and inventive flavor profiles makes it a standout choice for pizza enthusiasts in San Luis Obispo. 

Your friend makes some great pizza!

📍2324 Broad St, San Luis Obispo, CA 93401

No list of SLO CAL pizza places would be complete without mentioning My Friend Mike’s. Located in the heart of San Luis Obispo, this local favorite is all about creative flavors and high-quality pizzas. Mike, the namesake behind the pizzeria, has become somewhat of a dough legend, spending lots of time studying books on the science of bread. Using an excellently crafted dough recipe and house-made sauces, My Friend Mike’s serves up pies that are equal parts classic, crunchy and creative.   

Popular options include the “Lamb, Olive, Feta” and the “Shroomies,” a vegetarian masterpiece featuring mushrooms, mushroom oil, roasted garlic, onions, and fresh herbs. Whether you are a long-time local or just passing through, My Friend Mike’s offers a memorable slice of SLO CAL hospitality.